Thursday, September 1, 2016

Jerusalem and St. Louis in the Torah



But unto the place which God, your God shall choose out of all your tribes to place His name there, shall you seek the manifestation of His presence and there shall you come.
                                        Deuteronomy 12:5
“The place which God shall choose” is Jerusalem.                            
                                                   Midrash Sifrei


         Jerusalem is mentioned in the Bible 667 times, including the 26 times the name appears in the Aramaic form. Yet the name Yerushalayim is mentioned in the Torah as often as my home town, St. Louis is, not once! On the contrary, it seems the Torah goes out of its way to avoid naming to avoid naming Jerusalem. Our verse is the first of six times that this chapter of Deuteronomy uses the phrase "the place which G-d shall choose", rather than simply naming Jerusalem.
         Why does the Torah refrain from naming Jerusalem?
         In truth, we have parallels in the Torah. When Abram was told to leave his land, his birthplace and his father’s home, God did not inform Abram of the destination. God's instructions were "lech l'cha", go [Genesis 12:1]. Similarly, 62 years later, when Abraham faced the test of the akeda, the binding of his beloved son Isaac, God did not immediately inform Abraham of the exact destination. Again, God's instructions were "lech l'cha", "go to one of the hills of which I will tell you". [ibid. 22:2] It is not always clear at the outset where God is leading us. At times God's command is merely "lech l'cha", go and trust that all will be well.
         Maimonides, in his philosophical magnum opus, the Guide for the Perplexed, raised our question, and suggests three answers:

The fact that this place is not stated explicitly when mentioned in the Torah, and not designated, but only hinted at by means of the words "which the Lord shall choose", is due in my opinion to three wise considerations. The first is, lest the nations should hold fast to the place and fight for it with great violence, knowing that this place is the final purpose of the Law on earth. The second is, lest those who then owned the place ravage and devastate it to the limit of their power. The third, and this is the strongest, lest every tribe should demand that this place be within its allotted portion and should seek to conquer it, which would lead to conflict and sedition ....

            The most important reason the Torah avoids mentioning Jerusalem by name, says Maimonides, is to prevent its becoming a source of strife among the Tribes of Israel.
            The golden thread which runs through the history of Jerusalem, and in fact defines Jerusalem is the city's destiny in uniting Israel. Therefore, for Jerusalem to be a divisive factor is for Jerusalem to cease being itself!


No comments:

Post a Comment